Papa Johns - Middletown

This was the first time that I had their mushroom hoagie. It was AMAZING! I usually get Dominos, but now they have a minimum AND charge delivery! Thank you, Door Dash for offering this to me!!

The worst pizza I have ever had, will never eat here again

Can I get extra sauce? Extra cheese? And hand-tossed? Are you kidding me? Every time I order from them (and I always order extra sauce and extra cheese), the pizza is so thin it could be considered thin crust. The toppings are so scarce that it feels like I ordered light toppings. Avoid ordering from the Middletown store.

The food was enjoyable overall, but the garlic knots were quite dry and lacked sufficient garlic butter. This affected the overall taste when paired with the incorrect pizza sauce instead of the cheese sauce I had ordered. Hopefully the remaining knots are not too dry to eat today. I may have to prepare my own garlic butter to improve them. I likely won't be ordering the garlic knots again in the future.

The mushroom hoagie and jalapeno poppers at this restaurant are absolutely incredible and the best in town!