Prairie Pizza - Murdo

After 10 hours on the road, we were referred to this establishment by the hotel we were staying as this and Subway were the only places open on Sunday evening. There were 4 full tables, and upon ordering we were told it was take out only and it would be 40 minutes until our pizza was ready. While waiting, a table became available and we began clearing it so that we could sit down and enjoy our pizza. The “lady” (I’m being nice here) abruptly stated OUR pizzas were take out only and that they could barely keep up. Keep up with what?? there are only 4 tables!! We finally got our pizza, walked back to the hotel to eat it, and it was less than desirable. They boast about a cinnamon crust that serves as dessert when dipped in their “special” sauce, which is nothing more than powdered sugar and water. Whoever has left good reviews here for this place must have encountered a different person at the restaurant. She was extremely rude several times to a couple of us in our group, to put it mildly. If I could have, I would have taken the $5 tip off the total. If I hadn’t already paid, I would have walked out. My suggestion is to bypass this place at all costs and eat a nasty cold cut sandwich from subway…would have been better than this place.

So here's the deal. I stopped in without reading any reviews (which I prefer to do, if I read a bunch of negative comments it'll bias my opinion one way or another even if its pity stars because the waitress was nice but the food was hot trash and we were the first people in at 5 pm right when they opened so I figured she was just frazzled or something but now I see it's a ongoing trend lol ? I had to say HI as we were in there for a bit with uncomfortable silence which was returned warmly. She was SLAMMED within the first 15 mins she was open and solo handling it all like a pro. Was she Robin Williams friendly? No but she wasn't old man from up either. Im extremely personable but in those conditions I'd be stressed too.Now to the food... We ordered just a basic pep pizza expecting such and man were we in for a surprise. When we got our pie after about 20-25 mins (pretty dang good for everything she was doing! ??? I set it down on the table and opened it with a slap in the face smell of cinnamon. Now mind you I had someone serve me Cincinnati chili with any warning and man I was not a happy camper lol ? the entire pie smelled of cinnamon and after inspection I saw it was the crust braided into a desert. Wasn't excited but after eating it I have to say it was pretty dang good! They should definitely offer both, normal and cinnamon crust but it was something different and the kids loved it.

We stopped in on a random chance just grabbing a pizza on our road trip. We were so surprised by the pizza. The restaurant was adorable and the food amazing. Definitely would make sure to stop again when driving cross country

Great place to eat and town has really great museum.

Absolutely the worst pizza I've ever had!! Boneless wings tasted freezer burnt! The crust has cinnamon in it and you get 2 cups of frosting with that was disgusting. And they charged me a premium price to be disappointed. The atmosphere was cold and unwelcoming. I won't be back!!!