Rocky's. Pizzeria - Nutley

Buffalo chicken pizza is the best! Meatball Parm perfect bread is roasted exactly right. Always try new things.

First visit, random, no expectations. Had a small Italian sub and a bottle of house branded lemon ice tea. The sandwich was made quickly but carefully. I thought the bread was definitely better than most Mom Pop sub places. There was a good amount of meat, freshly sliced and the condiments (o v, onions etc. we're proportionate to the sandwich. The gentleman who took care of me was very pleasant. I'll come back and get a slice of pie soon. Oh, the ice tea was a notch above I felt.

2 Slices of Ricotta mozzarella ... Root Beer .. ALL Under $10

If you haven't tried this hidden gem, you're truly missing out! I've been eating here for years, and the pizza and food always taste fantastic. I absolutely love it! The owners are incredibly talented, which adds to the experience and makes it more than just a place to grab a bite. The authenticity here is unmatched.

It’s clear that I’m getting older, as I recall visiting this place 30 years ago when I was a child. I still remember that the best sandwiches I’ve ever had were from here. They were simple yet outstanding. I used to enjoy a breaded chicken sandwich with American cheese, crispy bacon bits (which are typically a pizza topping, but I specifically requested them for the sandwich), and mayo. I hadn’t had a sandwich that good until today.