Casey's - Steelville

The staff is incredibly welcoming and friendly. They also go out of their way to customize your pizza to your liking. The flavors were spot on, and you can definitely expect your pizza to be prepared just the way you want it!

Most recently, I ordered a pizza for delivery through their website, and they sent me the wrong pizza. By the time I finally got the right one, it was cold. Over the course of two years, I've felt more ripped off by this place than any gas station in town. They have never taken any steps to address my issues or make me a satisfied customer—no discounts or compensation for the mistakes. The customer service is very poor, and I am incredibly dissatisfied.

This is the second time I've ordered pizza and breadsticks from Casey's, and both times they were missing ingredients! The first order was a supreme specialty pizza, and they didn't have any mushrooms. The second was a taco pizza, which was missing onions and green peppers. If you can't provide all the ingredients, you shouldn't charge full price! Also, the chips on the taco pizza were stale. I'm really dissatisfied with my experience and wish there was another pizza place in town because I would definitely stop ordering from Casey's!

Another delicious fantastic pizza dinner from Caseys in Steelville. Family was just saying how much we are going to miss this place when we move next month and I realized we have probably had at least 50 pizzas down here and have never shared how much we love them! Every time every kind is so spot, plus deals. The specials are always a tasty steal! Definitely recommend! Thanks Caseys Team! Everyone's says slow, it's fine... don't be in such a hurry

The pizza and sweet tea are definitely my two favorites. Not a bad place to work if you are the kind of person who needs drama in their life. Like most places where the smaller the town the bigger the gossip, well yes it 's in this little shop too. I can 't complain much honestly because small town working America is exactly how I would describe the atmosphere in this quaint lil general store. The kitchen staff which i always called the happiest workers at Casey 's, they sure can work under pressure. Gets pretty busy back there as their famous pizza is constantly in demand for. The girls working the sub stations and front counters were all very welcoming and willing to do what it takes to make sure their customer leaves happy. Now like and place of em ppl payment, they did have a bad apple or two whom think they run the show even if they just started, but a long as you do your job, and when it 's slow, you know how to handle a broom or mop and can think outside the box when it comes to keeping busy, you will do well and can go far.