Gotham Burger - Teaneck

Had a good burger, but the frits were a little oily and were a little soggy. Service was good and fast. It was my first time and it smells great. Menu had some options that I would like to try.

Hi. I loved the dining experience and that the manager and owner asked how the foods were and how everything was. My grilled chicken salad was good and i love it with the sauté onions, which adds a nice touch. My sister said her fried chicken was delicious, it just didn't have so much flavor. It needed a few spices. Unfortunately, my dad said his burger meat was good, but the bun fell apart. My mom saw that they put the sauce on bun before the meat is cook, which causes the bun to become soggy. Also, my mom had a turkey burger and the juice spilled everywhere. Finally, the chocolate moose my dad had was delicious, but the presentation was horrible. It was in a little plastic cup and didnt look appetizing. IF it was in a bowl and had chocolate over it and in it it would look fantastic

I'm speaking from the point of view of someone not restricted by any dietary guidelines. So, I eat non kosher foods most of the time. I was hesitant to try this kosher restaurant because I was worried the portions would be small, but I ordered the Gotham Burger and it was amazing: sweet, savory and just all around delectable. $8) It comes with a special sauce, caramelized onions, tomato, and lettuce on a sturdy bun. I also added a beef fry $2) which is a way of frying beef so it tastes like bacon for those who don't consume pork). For someone who has had bacon, it was pretty darn close it had the flavor but obviously lacks some of the textural qualities of bacon, such as the fatty portions). Honestly, if you were wondering about trying this place, give it a chance. It's just unbelievable. I want to try the shakes and onion rings too...because if they can make a burger this awesome, I bet the rest of their items are top notch. update: onion rings a bit bland, but made very well. The shakes are creamy, sweet and absolutely wonderful. The fries are thick and chewy and taste better than the onion rings. The veggie burger is phenomenal I've actually ordered that as much as the beef burgers. The chicken sandwich is huge. I don't care for all the seeds on the bread but the chicken and toppings were delicious. I'll probably stick to just ordering shakes and either the beef or veggie burgers with beef fry. The marinated mushrooms have a strong taste and are worth trying. I haven't had the chili yet, nor the mousse or peanut butter pie. The apple pie's crust tasted stale to me. I didn't like it.

Ordered regular burger with beef fry black and blue. Cooked perfectly.

The burgers here are incredibly juicy and grilled to perfection. I like to add the beef frit, which is similar to bacon and has a delightful sweet glaze. The sauces pack a flavorful punch and are truly enjoyable. I especially love the strawberry shaker. The fries are well-seasoned, even slightly better than the onion rings. I found the apple cake to be underwhelming, but I’m excited to try the peanut butter cake next. The veggie burgers feature a patty that tastes like the best falafel you can imagine. Overall, this restaurant is my favorite spot to relax and enjoy a meal. The owner is attentive, gracious, and talented. There's a reason this place is always packed!