Bagelicious Cafe - Terryville

I am a city person who moved here 30years ago...Bagelicious comes close to my favorite place in the city. LOVE these BAGELS. THE BEST in the area.

My favorite bagel shop in Long Island. Can't go wrong with their sausage egg and cheese on an everything bagel.

My go to bagel store while in Port Jefferson area. Solid fresh bagels and good ice coffee. You cannot go wrong. Strawberry cream cheese... it is amazing!

Disorganized, can't get orders right, confused, low quality of food. Expensive . Used to be a good spot. $4 for a old small buttered bagel you need to order twice is frustrating.

Food, service, and atmosphere were ok, but who charges over 9 bucks for a bacon, egg and cheese? My usual bagel spot in SI charges less than 6 bucks. There was nothing special about the sandwich that would justify the price.