Mccolley's Pie Company Is Now Great Lakes Pie Company, Llc

Bought a cherry pie today and had a piece with a little vanilla ice cream for dessert. So good! Home-made goodness at a reasonable price! Definitely worth the trip!

Great pies. Bought an apple and a peach pie. Both were awesome.

We come to the area every summer and were tasked with procuring a Cherry Pie for the group. After a frantic search, we came across this gem and decided to take a detour to give it a try. We will definitely be back next year. We took home a cheery Pie, small rhubarb pie, fresh cherries, and cherry salsa (I was hungry). Every single thing was delicious. We were pleasantly surprised that the salsa had a tiny bit of heat and the faintest hint of cherry, it was great!

This place has great gluten free pies! We stopped while on vacation to place our order and picked up our half apple half cherry pie before we left to head home. We appreciate being able to eat gluten free local products.

If Grandma was a good cook and really knew how to bake these pies are just like that.