Hartzler Family Dairy - Wooster

The PB sundae was absolutely delicious! We were even able to get a smaller version for half the price.

My daughter gave us eggnog that she bought but didn't use during Christmas. It stayed in the fridge until I decided to open it recently. I have tried eggnog from different places before, but they always seemed too thin and lacked flavor. Yours was the best I've ever had! It was creamy, perfectly seasoned, and it blended perfectly with rum. I will definitely be purchasing it again and recommending it to everyone I know!

This was the worst strawberry ice cream I have ever tasted. I usually enjoy supporting family-owned restaurants, but I felt compelled to leave this review after discreetly informing the staff that the ice cream was not up to par and they chose to keep selling it. They did offer a replacement, but I declined as I was not interested in trying more. I even purchased some merchandise while waiting for the ice cream, but I was disappointed by the quality of both the strawberry and butter pecan flavors. My whole family agreed that the butter pecan was also subpar - bland, watery, and tasting artificial. If they had taken the ice cream off the shelf, I wouldn't have felt the need to write this review.

Why in the world a supposedly small family dairy chooses to put artificial ingredients in their eggnog is beyond me.

The ice cream and milkshakes at this restaurant are delicious. The service is good and the location is convenient. The establishment is clean, but the prices are a bit high.