Godfather's Pizza Express - Atkinson

Gross! What a waste of money! I ordered two large golden crust pizzas. We get there and was told they only had 1 golden crust so they made the other thin crust! Would’ve been nice to have a phone call to let us know! We took the pizza home and they were both burnt! Both are thin crust and taste like salt licks! I won’t go to this location ever again! It’s almost like they don’t know there’s other godfathers locations and I don’t know any better! Expensive dog food but they enjoyed it! On the other hand my family had to eat something else while I tried to choke a piece down! They didn’t even give us pizza in a godfathers box it was in a Subway box! I wish I had the money back because it was a complete waste! Moral of the story stay away from this godfathers!

Employees were great, my pickle pizza was perfect. Young man that made our pizzas was a gem.I hope they're paid a decent wage to run multiple stores. 4 folks for 3 stores during the dinner hour , that's insane.The website blows. Tried to order online but pickles wasn't an option, even when I selected the bacon burger pizza. Then our order was rejected using both card and cash options. I understand the need to pause or turn off online orders, my issue is not being notified until after choosing and customizing each order and entering CC info.

The 4 time in the last month after ordering pizzas on the website, they give a pick up time, we go there to pick up our order the pizzas are not done, they say trouble with their tablet or they didn't recieve the order. So I show them our order confirmation number the pick up time. So 1 hour 20 mins after the original pick up is when the food was ready!

I love their pizza! Very yummy deep dish style with lots of cheese. Very conveniently located off hwy 20. I enjoy the personal pizzas to go.

Godfather’s pizza has excellent tangy pizza sauce! They put plenty of toppings and the pizza crust is delish! I had never had Godfather’s pizza and was needing a quick bite while traveling. Thankfully, they had ready made pizzas and I got a small one. I was pleasantly surprised. It was a little dry as you might expect with a ready made, but i was blown away by the great ROBUST flavor. Needless to say, I came back to try a freshly made pizza and was not disappointed! SO good. Godfather’s is now my go to pizza. So glad they’re in my area! The price is great, too!